Open Access Paper
12 July 2019 Detector development activities supported by the European Space Agency
Heidrun Weber, Nick Nelms, Kyriaki Minoglou, Alessandra Ciapponi, Sarah Wittig, Bruno Leone
Author Affiliations +
Proceedings Volume 11180, International Conference on Space Optics — ICSO 2018; 111803R (2019) https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2536054
Event: International Conference on Space Optics - ICSO 2018, 2018, Chania, Greece
Abstract
Detectors play a crucial role for the instrument design and the achievable instrument performance. The wavebands of interest for remote sensing are the visible and the infrared. Therefore, the European Space Agency has a strong interest in the performance enhancement of detector arrays in those spectral ranges. The Agency follows a continuous development strategy to enhance the capabilities for future Earth observation and astronomy missions. This paper presents the technical and planning status of these detector technology development activities.

1.

INTRODUCTION

Detectors form a cornerstone in the measurement capabilities of space missions, and consequently the European Space Agency (ESA) is always concerned to have the highest possible detector performance available to instrument developers. In this overview we report on the present and future detector development activities for the European Space Agency Science and Earth Observation Program, focusing on the developments in the visible to infrared wavelength range.

These developments cover entire new detector developments, evaluation of existing detectors under environmental conditions, and modifications of existing designs. The overall strategic approach uses both technology-push and technology-pull. For example, a new detector development can be linked to a specific mission and therefore, its requirements are based on the mission needs. On the other hand, a detector development can be initiated to increase the TRL of a technology and show that basic performances can be achieved.

Currently, three roadmaps have been defined and cover:

  • NIR Large Format Sensor Array (ALFA-N) Technology Development Plan

    Program aimed at developing a 2K × 2K, very low noise, very low dark current, MCT array with the supporting ASIC.

  • Low Dark Current 2D MWIR to VLWIR MCT Detectors Technology Development Plan

    Coordination and synergy of detector development activities at ESA aiming towards the next generation of MCT 2D MWIR to LWIR detectors.

  • European CMOS Image Sensor Technology Development Plan

    Two-phase program aimed at investigating and supporting European CMOS foundry interest and capability for development of high performance image sensors.

The ALFA-NIR and ALFA-Controller roadmap is shown in Figure 1 where the ALFA-N phase 1 and 2 are finished and phase 3 is on-going. For the ALFA-Controller, the phase 1 is finished and the phase 2 is kicked-off.

Figure 1

ALFA-NIR and ALFA-Controller roadmap

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_3_1.jpg

The MWIR/LWIR detector development roadmap is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2

Coordinated development activities related to MWIR/LWIR/VLWIR MCT detector developments for both Earth Observation and Science missions

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_3_2.jpg

The European CMOS development roadmap initially pursued two themes:

  • European High flux CMOS Image Sensor

    Earth observation applications – high charge handling capacity

  • European Low flux CMOS Image Sensor

Science/astronomy applications – low noise

Following changes in the European foundry landscape, only the low flux development is now on-on-going. However, the remit of the low flux CIS development has been expanded to cover both higher and lower signal applications.

The next chapter presents both the detector developments in support of these roadmaps and strategic developments that are in addition. They are sorted as much as possible by wavelength, going from the visible to the infrared.

2.

DETECTOR DEVELOPMENTS

2.1

European low flux CMOS image sensor

The low-flux CIS activity began in early 2016 led by Caeleste (Belgium). Caeleste is responsible for the design of the chip and LFoundry (Italy) for the manufacturing. The goal of the activity is to develop a radiation hard, charge domain global shutter, high dynamic range pixel for low flux / high flux space applications. The initial sensor design (see Figure 3) is back-thinned and has the following specification:

  • Matrix (4x3) of stitch blocks of 480x360 pixels

  • Rad hard 15μm 4T

  • 16 differential outputs

  • Read Noise <5e

  • Dark Current beginning of life < 50pA/cm2, end of life< 200pA/cm2

  • FWC:200Ke- (low gain), FWC: 7.5Ke- (high gain)

Figure 3

Left: Frontside chip of the European Low-Flux CIS packaged on chip-on-board. Right: detector architecture

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_4_1.jpg

In 2017, first images were acquired using the first front side illuminated samples. However, unexpected high pining voltages were measured on test structures. As a result, a second run of wafers with optimized implantations started and currently the backside thinning of those new wafers is taking place. First backside packaged samples are expected to be ready by end of 2018.

2.2

High-performance silicon visible hybrid CMOS image sensor

In addition to monolithic CMOS image sensors, the Agency seeks for developing a hybrid CMOS visible image sensor. Being hybrid, the manufactured detector is less sensitive to parasitic light and allows for separate optimization of the ROIC and the photodiode layer.

The goal of the activity is to demonstrate the potential of hybrid technology for high-performance silicon visible CMOS image sensors. The activity was granted to Teledyne-e2v (UK) and Leonardo (UK). The design of a dedicated ROIC was considered to be out of the scope of this activity. Efforts are instead focused on the photodiode design and the hybridization. The requirements are defined as follows:

  • Si 2D photodiode array (PDA). Target thickness 300μm, full depletion at <50V

  • ROIC: Selex ME930

    • 15μm pitch, 1280x1024 pixels

    • Part of the large format NIR array program

    • Designed for low flux, low read noise and for scaling up to a 2k × 2k array format.

    • 4, 8, 16, or 32 analogue video outputs

    • Source-follower with elements of radiation-hard design

The first run of manufacturing of the photodiode wafer, the post processing of ROIC wafer and the hybridization are completed (see Figure 4). The first packaged samples are under test and the first image was acquired. The second manufacturing run implementing small corrections on the design and process is currently taking place. The new batch of wafers are in progress and wafers are at the backthinning step. In October 2018 first packaged devices will be available.

Figure 4

Left: Hybrid CIS assembly. Right: Packaged hybrid CIS

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_5_1.jpg

2.3

Performance characterization and comparison of P-channel and N-channel CCD devices

This study explores the defects created in both N- and P-channel CCD204s when irradiated by protons, looking at defect type and mobility post-irradiation. Two irradiations were performed under cryogenic conditions (at 153K and 203K), with the devices held at mid-point temperature (173K) between irradiations. The performance characterization was held for three weeks at each temperature. The study was led by the Open University and the results are presented in [1].

The devices were tested pre- and post-proton irradiation for opto-electronic performance and showed comparable results. The study indicates that P-channel CCDs are superior in post-irradiation performance to N-channel CCDs for certain in-flight operating conditions and could increase operational mission lifetime due to their robustness against radiation damage (see Figure 5). Additionally, the activity brought new knowledge of trap species and densities in both N- and P-channel CCDs, which are an important asset for the design of future scientific instruments.

Figure 5

Left: Setup P- and N-channel CCDs with associated headboard electronics mounted to the copper cryogenic cold bench. Right: Factor difference in performance for both the P- and N-Channel after irradiation at 153K. Pre-irradiation CTI has been subtracted.

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_6_1.jpg

2.4

Curved detectors

Curved focal plane detectors offer a well-known method for simplifying the optical design without sacrificing performance for many applications. The reduction in mass and volume offered by the utilization of such detector arrays can clearly help in achieving these key objectives of space instrument design. The aim of this activity is to demonstrate that existing, high-performance 2D detector arrays (CCD or CIS), already used in space applications, can be successfully curved and still meet both performance and environmental requirements.

This activity encompasses the following tasks:

  • - Procurement of planar detector

  • - Post-processing of a subset of devices to curve them at a certain radius

  • - Characterization of the electro-optical performance

  • - Comparison to the equivalent flat detector

  • - Validation of environmental suitability for future space applications

The contract is currently under negotiation, will start in Q3 2018 and is foreseen to be finished mid 2019.

2.5

The ALFA program

In 2010, the Agency initiated an ambitious, multi-activity program to develop a large-format (2k × 2k pixels) NIR detector array and associated control ASIC (application specific integrated circuit). The key aims of this program are to develop a photon to space wire system according to the roadmap shown in Figure 1.

The detector tested [2] at the end of phase two (see Figure 1) showed very promising results (see Figure 7). The best detector, the CEA/LETI (FR) LPE device (640*512 pixels, 15μm pitch), has been proton and then gamma irradiated. The results after the proton radiation are presented in [3] and show an increase of only 24% of the dark current after irradiation up to a fluence of 2.27e11p+ .cm-2.

The program is at present in phase three led by Sofradir (FR) [4] and has the goal to design, manufacture and characterize a large format 2D array MCT array (shown in Figure 6) with the following parameters:

Cut-off wavelength2.1 μm
Cut-on wavelength0.8 μm
QE>70% with ARC
No. pixels2048 × 2048
Pixel size15 × 15 μm2
CHC60 ke-
Read-noise<18 e-rms (single CDS)
Dark current0.1 e/p/s @ 100K
No. outputs32 (read-out through 1,4 or 32)
Non-destructive readout possible

Figure 6

Format of ALFA-N large format MCT array.

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_7_1.jpg

Figure 7

Quantum efficiency measured on detectors as deliverable from the ALFA-N Phase 2 roadmap

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_7_2.jpg

The detailed design review has been completed successfully and the ROIC is under manufacture with the foundry. It is expected to be delivered in July this year with first ROIC level results available in the autumn.

Control ASIC developments

The Agency is supporting the development of versatile control ASICs to be able to control and read out a CMOS based detector.

In this context, two separate activities are on-going. The first one targets Earth Observation applications and the second one Science/Astronomy applications and in particular the ALFA-N detector as shown in Figure 1.

The Earth Observation targeted activity is run by Ideas (Norway) developing the NIRCA mkII. This ASIC shall be (see Figure 8) capable of providing clocks and bias voltages to operate the detector as well as providing video processing and digitisation (16 channels, 14 bit, up to 12 Msps), leading to a two-chip detection system (ASIC + detector). The NIRCA mkII is designed to be interface-compatible as a minimum with the Sofradir NGP detector and the Leonardo ME950. The critical design review is planned for November 2018.

Figure 8

Schematic layout of the control ASIC

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_8_1.jpg

The Science oriented activity aims to further develop a cryogenic, control and digitization application specific integrated circuit predominantly for optimized large area NIR/SWIR detector hybrids. After the phase 1 of the activity a prototype ASIC developed by Caeleste (BE) has been tested [5] using a dedicated test setup at ESTEC (see Figure 9).

Figure 9

Test set-up for prototype ASIC testing at ESTEC

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_9_1.jpg

For the second phase, after reissue, the activity is run by Caeleste with a kick-off in June 2018. It shall contain 36 video channels at a read-out speed of 100kHz at 16-bit/5MHz at 12-bit. It foresees a programmable seqencer for clocks and bias. The completion of the activity is scheduled for end of 2019.

2.6

Optimization of long, modular linear InGaAs imagers.

This activity aims to develop the next generation of long-linear InGaAs arrays with improved noise performance for commercial applications. This activity was granted to Xenics in Belgium.

The specifications are the following:

  • Pixel : Standard SWIR InGaAs (1.7μm cut-off)

  • Array : 1 × 2048 pixels

  • ROIC: stitched CMOS OnSemi 0.18μm

  • Configuration : 8 or 16 analog video channels at 60 MHz

The heritage of this activity is the previous successful development for the Proba-V sensor with 3000 pixels, 25μm pitch and wire bonded. In the on-going activity, where the flip chip approach is replacing the wire bonding, currently a demonstrator with one 2k linear InGaAs chip wire bonded on a PCB is successfully fabricated. An appropriate custom ceramic package has been developed (see Figure 10). The noise optimization of the camera hardware/software and full characterization is on-going.

Figure 10

Left: Picture of one assembled FPA. Right: Custom ceramic package

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_9_2.jpg

2.7

Development of Low Dark Current MWIR/LWIR detectors

This development runs with two parallel contracts. The first one is led by AIM (DE) with Caeleste (BE) designing the ROIC and University of Cardiff (UK) for the characterization. The second one is led by Sofradir (FR) with CEA-LETI and CEA-SAP (FR) for design and characterization of the detectors.

The study is performance oriented and does not focus on any specific MCT technology or and specific ROIC architecture.

The key requirements for the activities are:

  • Cut-off wavelength 12.5μm at 40K

  • Dark current density < 2.5e-11A.cm-2 at 40K

  • Detection efficiency ≥ 60%

Sofradir have manufactured the detectors and started the characterizations of the chosen ROIC. In order to reach the 40K operating temperature, the setup has been updated and the characterization of the hybrid will start in the coming months.

In the AIM activity, also a design of a new ROIC with 4 read out segments (7T-CTIA, 5T-CTIA non-rad, 5T-CTIA rad-hard, SFD) has been developed. Characterization of the final demonstrators (n-on-p and p-on-n MCT materials) is on-going in Cardiff University. First results are very promising for the improvement of the dark current.

2.8

Low Dark current VLWIR T2SL Infrared detectors

The goal of the activity is to evaluate T2SL (type-II superlattice) detectors for space applications through the design, manufacture and test of high performance, low dark current VLWIR detector arrays using COTS ROIC and compare them with established technology.

The tested devices from IRNOVA (SE) have the following specifications:

  • InAs/GaSb and InAs/InAsSb (Ga-free) T2SL options

  • COTS ROIC (FLIR Systems):

  • 320×256 array size, 30μm pixel pitch

  • 384×288 array size, 25μm pixel pitch

The growth development, process development and detector fabrication/evaluation are in progress (see Figure 11).

Figure 11

Left: FLIR Indigo ISC0208 ROIC mounted on a LCC68 socket, before integration in ADS test set-up for electrical functional test. Right: Schematic depicting the band structure of the absorption region in a GaSb-InAs type II strained superlattice device.

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_10_1.jpg

The detailed design review took place in November 2017, but the best design option requires non-standard ROIC, therefore additional funding will be injected in the activity.

2.9

Evaluation of MCT APD Detectors for future space applications

Future astronomy missions require a low dark current, but in particular a very low noise contribution from the readout noise. In the standard photodiode architecture, the readout noise main contributor is coming from the first stage of the amplification. The technology offered by Avalanche Photodiode (APD) allows reducing the readout noise by creating an internal amplification where the photoelectrons are created under a high electric field. Current APD application are targeted to ground base astronomy [6], but this technology is also promising for future space missions.

The goal of the activity is to test and characterize existing European MCT APD arrays in a radiation environment.

The selected device is the ‘Saphira’ from Leonardo (UK) (see Figure 12) with the following performances:

  • 320 × 256 × 24 μm pixels

  • Baseline dark current ~0.03 e-/s

  • Avalanche gain > 500

A total of two irradiation campaigns have been performed:

  • TID radiation – 2 devices at 100 K

  • Proton irradiation - 2 devices at 100 K and 2 devices at 293K

Figure 12

SAPHIRA Avalanche Photodiode Array [datasheet from Leonardo]

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_11_1.jpg

Figure 13

Schematic detector layout of CHIME detector pre-development

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_12_1.jpg

Figure 14

Schematic detector layout of LSTM detector pre-development

00158_PSISDG11180_111803R_page_14_1.jpg

The analysis of results is concluded and no degradation in performance has been observed for TID up to 28 krad (biased) and 56 krad (unbiased). Although some technical difficulties with the proton test occurred, no degradation was observed for irradiation up to 5.92E10 p/cm2 at 62 MeV.

2.10

Copernicus pre-developments

In the frame of the “Copernicus Space Component Expansion” programme new missions have been identified by the European Commission (EC) as priorities for implementation in the coming years by providing additional capabilities in support of current emerging user needs. As part of the preparatory activities for the evolution of Copernicus, Phase A/B1 studies are being undertaken for 6 high priority candidate Expansion Sentinels, namely:

  • Anthropogenic CO2 Monitoring Mission (CO2M)

  • Land Surface Temperature Monitoring Mission (LSTM)

  • Polar Ice and Snow Topographic Mission (PICE)

  • Passive Microwave Imaging Mission (CIMR)

  • HyperSpectral Imaging Mission (CHIME)

  • L-band SAR Mission (ROSE-L)

Each of the three optical candidate missions is accompanied by a dedicated detector pre-development programme. It is initiated in order to support the fulfillment of the mission goals, but also to build up future capabilities.

CHIME detector pre-development

The Copernicus Hyperspectral Imaging Mission for the Environment (CHIME) [8] aims to augment the Copernicus space component with precise spectroscopic measurements to derive quantitative surface characteristics supporting the monitoring, implementation and improvement of a range of policies in the domain of raw materials, agriculture, soils, food security, biodiversity, environmental degradation and hazards, inland and coastal waters, snow, forestry and the urban environment.

The pre-development of a detector optimised for meeting the mission needs of the Hyperspectral Imaging Mission is being initiated. The major improvement required with respect to existing detectors is the development of large detector arrays covering the visible to short-wave infrared while supporting a high frame rate. Such detectors with performance optimised for this mission are currently not available from European suppliers. Key requirements of the CHIME detector pre-development are:

  • Spectral range 400-2500nm

  • Format 2k × 512

  • 20 μm pixel pitch

  • Charge handling capacity (CHC): 1.4 Me- (low gain), 700 ke- (high gain)

  • Readout noise: 250e- (low gain), 150e- (high gain)

  • Spectral Detection Efficiency > 80% (minimum 70%)

  • Minimum frame rate 230 Hz

  • ROIC functionalities: individual de-selection of rows, Gain switch per row with 4 (2) different values

The contract has been awarded to AIM (DE), the kick-off took place begin of August 2018. The requirements review is foreseen for end of August 2018. The overall planned duration of the baseline activity is 24 months.

CO2M detector pre-development

The Anthropogenic CO2 monitoring (CO2M) mission aims to analyse through the use of CO2 satellite imagers the man-made CO2 emissions and overall CO2 budget at country and regional/megacity scales.

Key requirements of the CO2M detector pre-development are:

  • Spectral range NIR: 0.747-0.773 μm, SWIR-1: 1.590-1.675 μm, SWIR-2: 1.925-2.095 μm

  • Format 2000 × 1100

  • 15-20 μm pixel pitch

  • Gain switch per row with 2 different values

  • ROIC design: compatible with modular detector topology

  • Charge handling capacity (CHC): >600 ke- (High gain:≤250 ke-, Low gain: ≥600 ke-)

  • Readout noise: <125e- (High gain:<80e-, Low gain:<125e-)

  • Spectral Detection Efficiency > 80%

  • ROIC functionalities: windowing: de-selection of rows

The activity is expected to kick-off in November 2018 and the overall planned duration of the baseline activity is 24 months.

LSTM detector pre-development

The High Spatio-Temporal Resolution Land Surface Temperature (LST) Monitoring Mission shall be able to complement the current visible (VIS) and near-infrared (NIR) Copernicus observations with high spatio-temporal resolution Thermal Infrared observations over land and coastal regions.

Key requirements of the LSTM detector pre-development are:

  • Five spectral bands centered on: 8.6 μm, 8.9 μm, 9.2 μm, 10.9 μm and 12 μm

  • No. pixels         1024 × 10 per band (TBC)

  • Pixel size          20-30 μm square

  • Frame rate           5 kHz (TBC) •

  • Charge handling capacity (CHC): selectable per spectral channel: 4.5, 6 and 8 Me-

  • Spectral Detection Efficiency   > 45% to 65% depending on the spectral band

  • Nominal operating temperature: > 60K

  • Windowing and pixel selection functionalities

The pre-development is expected to kick-off in September/October 2018 and the overall planned duration of the baseline activity is 24 months.

3.

CONCLUSIONS

The European Space Agency recognizes the importance of not only improving and optimizing the performance of detectors but also in supporting their continued availability. To this end, ESA continues to develop and maintain its strategic approach to detector developments, using both technology-push and technology-pull, through both internal and external consultation, resulting in the initiation of targeted detector development activities across the waveband.

REFERENCES

[1] 

Nathan L. Bush, et al., “A comparison of proton damage effects on P- and N-Channel CCDs I: performance following cryogenic irradiation,” in SPIE Astronomical Telescopes + Instrumentation, (2018). https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2313447 Google Scholar

[2] 

P-E. Crouzet, et al., “First characterization of the NIR European Large Format Array detectors at ESTEC,” in SPIE, (2015). Google Scholar

[3] 

D. Gooding et al., “Large format array NIR detectors for future ESA astronomy missions: characterization and comparison,” in Proceedings, (2016). https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2231179 Google Scholar

[4] 

Bruno Fièque, et al., “Development of astronomy large focal plane array “ALFA” at Sofradir and CEA,” in SPIE Astronomical Telescopes + Instrumentation, (2018). https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2311713 Google Scholar

[5] 

F. Lemmel et al., “Large format array controller (aLFA-C): tests and characterisation at ESA,” in Proceedings, (2016). Google Scholar

[6] 

Dani Atkinson; Donald Hall; Christoph Baranec; Ian Baker; Shane Jacobson and Reed Riddle, “Observatory deployment and characterization of SAPHIRA HgCdTe APD arrays,” in Proc. SPIE, (2014). https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2056807 Google Scholar

[7] 

Peter R. Roelfsema, et al., “SPICA: a joint infrared space observatory,” in SPIE Astronomical Telescopes + Instrumentation, (2018). Google Scholar

[8] 

Nieke, J. and M. Rast, “Towards the Copernicus Hyperspectral Imaging Mission (CHIME),” (2018). https://doi.org/10.1109/IGARSS.2018.8518384 Google Scholar
© (2019) COPYRIGHT Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE). Downloading of the abstract is permitted for personal use only.
Heidrun Weber, Nick Nelms, Kyriaki Minoglou, Alessandra Ciapponi, Sarah Wittig, and Bruno Leone "Detector development activities supported by the European Space Agency", Proc. SPIE 11180, International Conference on Space Optics — ICSO 2018, 111803R (12 July 2019); https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2536054
Advertisement
Advertisement
RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS
Get copyright permission  Get copyright permission on Copyright Marketplace
KEYWORDS
Sensors

Detector development

Readout integrated circuits

CMOS sensors

Manufacturing

Charge-coupled devices

Detector arrays

RELATED CONTENT

Toward 16 megapixel focal plane arrays
Proceedings of SPIE (September 26 2007)
1024 x 1024 Si As IBC detector arrays for mid...
Proceedings of SPIE (June 15 2006)
2K X 2K InSb for astronomy
Proceedings of SPIE (September 29 2004)

Back to Top